AI’s impact has rapidly expanded across various industries and regions. It has helped businesses unlock new opportunities, supported cities in enhancing their services and empowered leaders to achieve greater efficiency, innovation and growth.
Despite the AI market’s explosive growth — projections estimate it could reach USD 757.58 billion by 2025 — many leaders continue to face a key challenge: proving a clear return on investment (ROI) from AI initiatives.
Measuring AI success is essential for ensuring alignment with business goals, driving long-term value, empowering data-driven decision-making and optimizing performance and resource allocation. Without a clear framework for assessing ROI, wasted resources and missed opportunities could overshadow AI’s potential.
Understanding a project’s ROI is essential for businesses and investors. However, when it comes to AI projects, the definition and approach for measuring ROI require a more nuanced perspective that captures both tangible and intangible benefits.
Traditional ROI typically focuses on easily measurable financial results and metrics, such as boosted sales, higher profit margins or improved Net Promoter Scores (NPS). These metrics are clear-cut and directly tied to revenue or cost savings, making them relatively simple to track and interpret. For instance, an increase in sales or customer retention can directly showcase the success of a specific initiative.
AI-specific ROI differs by focusing on broader and less immediately quantifiable benefits. Despite the financial gains it provides, AI’s actual value often lies in benefits such as improved operational efficiency, increased innovation or enhanced competitive advantage. Measuring these benefits — particularly understanding how they directly lead to financial profits — can be challenging. However, their impact on long-term business success makes them essential metrics to assess.
Although automation has significant value, measuring its benefits in the short term can be challenging. However, over time, the increase in efficiency can significantly lower operational costs and enhance capacity. For the training incubator, integrating an AI-driven customer service platform translated into potential annual savings of $120K.
AI and data tools that enhance decision-making, automate repetitive tasks or provide predictive insights can help employees save time and concentrate on more strategic activities.
This was the case for Waggel, a fast-growing pet insurance provider that implemented a comprehensive data management platform to streamline its data organization. The platform empowered their teams to extract meaningful insights and make faster, more precise decisions. While capturing the direct financial impact can be challenging, the overall increase in productivity can lead to long-term value.
AI drives innovation by enabling businesses to create new products, services or business models. This innovation, combined with AI’s ability to provide rich insights, offers companies a competitive advantage that can pay off in the future, even if the financial impact isn’t immediately visible.
For example, when digital media and SaaS company OTTera identified the need for enhanced business intelligence and advanced analytics, it adopted cutting-edge data analytics software. This capability allowed it to gain deeper insights into its market, customers, competitors and offerings. As a result, OTTera gained a competitive advantage, successfully expanded into new markets and became one of the fastest-growing PaaS providers globally.
Ultimately, measuring AI-specific ROI requires a shift in thinking — moving from conventional, immediate financial results to a broader understanding of strategic value. By evaluating measurable and non-quantifiable indicators, companies gain clearer insight into how AI enhances efficiency and fosters growth. This new mindset positions them for long-term success in a fast-changing business environment.
Identifying and defining the right metrics is essential for accurately assessing the success of AI initiatives. By establishing both pre- and post-project metrics, organizations can create a clear framework for measuring impact and driving continuous improvement.
Pre-project metrics — often identified before implementing AI — are key for assessing progress and impact. These baseline metrics include customer/employee satisfaction scores, sales performance and error rates.
However, these metrics must be tailored to an organization’s unique needs and business objectives. Every AI initiative should aim to answer two key questions: what business problem does it address, and how does it advance our strategic goals? Therefore, the pre-project metrics must be tied to measurable and actionable outcomes.
It’s also essential to understand the baseline for AI success and provide a clear starting point to measure improvements post-AI implementation. Conducting research can help identify this baseline to know where the company operates and how AI can drive improvement. The research can also help identify gaps or inconsistencies in data that must be addressed before deploying AI solutions.
Once the AI initiative is underway, companies can use post-project metrics to evaluate its impact and effectiveness. For example, metrics such as CSAT scores, error rates or cost-saving calculations can help measure tangible changes in efficiency, accuracy or customer satisfaction.
Moreover, observing these metrics can offer rich insights for continuous improvement. This approach enables companies to understand how products/services perform and where to make necessary adjustments. It also validates the business value of the offering and empowers companies to make data-driven decisions for future initiatives.
AI’s direct impact is often the most tangible and measurable. Various solutions, such as GenAI chatbots, can reduce labor costs and operational expenses as fewer humans are needed. Similarly, solutions such as an AI-enabled Hydraulic Network Risk Tool can help companies proactively predict and tackle risk, resulting in millions in cost savings.
In addition to these savings, AI can contribute to higher sales volumes or open up new revenue streams. Whether through personalized product recommendations or improved demand forecasting, AI helps companies better meet customer needs, leading to growth in sales and revenue.
AI also offers indirect benefits that provide companies significant and often long-term value. For example, various AI solutions equip organizations with data-driven insights to optimize existing offerings and processes and plan for the future. Although it can be challenging to quantify the impact of improved decision-making in figures, its value is undeniable in the long term.
Another indirect impact that’s difficult to measure is enhanced innovation. AI solutions such as ChatGPT enable teams to explore new ideas, develop innovative solutions and push the boundaries of what’s possible. However, the ROI of increased innovation can only be quantified over a long period.
These indirect benefits can be measured in various ways, including surveys, feedback forms and other qualitative measures. The goal of these endeavors is to capture various perspectives from employees, customers and stakeholders to paint a clearer picture of AI’s impact.
AI’s long-term impact is where its true potential often lies. Its benefits materialize over time, making way for more significant wins. As such, forecasting the future benefits of AI is essential to understanding its strategic value.
For instance, it can be crucial for success to recognize how AI can help a business gain a competitive advantage, position itself to expand into new markets or outperform competitors in existing ones. Netflix, the world’s largest streaming platform, has continued to leverage AI to personalize viewer recommendations. This unique feature has enabled them to gain over 280 million subscribers globally and $14.5 billion in revenue.
Beyond increased market share, AI can contribute to exponential growth, new opportunities and accelerated business performance. The quality of AI models often hinges on the quality and quantity of data available. As data accumulates, AI models improve, leading to more impact and business value over time.
Ultimately, organizations can fully understand AI’s transformative power by evaluating these direct, indirect and long-term impacts. This also ensures investments align with immediate objectives and future growth potential.
Measuring ROI effectively requires a structured approach to evaluate AI’s impact on business outcomes. Here are seven best practices to consider:
Calculating AI’s ROI can be challenging given the complexity of AI technologies, the evolving nature of business environments and the difficulty of quantifying specific outcomes. Intangible benefits such as improved customer satisfaction may not immediately result in increased revenue but could impact other factors such as brand loyalty and long-term growth. Developing the right metrics to capture these intangible benefits often involves complex calculations and sophisticated frameworks that may not be easily understood.
The lack of a standard set of metrics to assess AI success across industries further complicates the process. Companies must develop measurement frameworks based on their goals, technologies and business context. These frameworks must also account for AI systems deploying alongside other concurrent business initiatives. As such, the frameworks may require advanced modeling technologies to evaluate AI’s direct impact.
Another key challenge in measuring AI’s ROI is data quality issues. AI projects rely on high-quality, reliable data to generate meaningful insights. Poor data can undermine the project’s effectiveness, skew business decisions and make it harder to attribute clear ROI.
Integrating AI systems into existing business processes can also be complex and may pose additional challenges in measuring their impact. Improper integration or severe disruptions to normal operations could lead to underperformance or missed opportunities.
Finally, estimating the costs associated with AI projects can be challenging, as they fluctuate over time due to maintenance, updates or scaling efforts. Without a clear understanding of all costs, organizations risk overestimating or underestimating the actual financial outlay required for the project.
AI is a powerful and strategic tool that can drive business transformation. However, as organizations continue to invest in AI, they must effectively identify and define how to measure its ROI to ensure they get the most out of their investments.
Other articles that may interest you
